Riporto di seguito, le recensioni relative ai Brunello di Montalcino 2016, redatte dalla professionista molto preparata Kerin O’Keefe, corrispondente per l’Italia della rivista statunitense WineEnthusiast, il cui sito web è : Winemag.com
Furbescamente qualcuno in Italia, improvvisatosi giornalista del vino, proveniente da altri settori totalmente estranei alla materia vino, ha pensato di copiare il nome del sito americano, forse nella illusione o speranza di trarre in equivoco ( o inganno ) qualche azienda italiana e straniera !
Cosi’ dichiara Kerin nel suo sito :
“Ho assaggiato 199 delle nuove uscite di Brunello nel mio ufficio tra dicembre e gennaio: le degustazioni hanno rivelato una grandiosità dell’annata ma anche sfide che la denominazione deve affrontare. Le sessioni sono state di 20 vini al giorno “.
![Il Presidente del Consorzio Fabrizio Bindocci](https://www.winetaste.it/wp-content/uploads/2021/03/Presidente_Fabrizio_Bindocci-947x1024.jpg)
Gli improvvisati dichiarano invece di avere degustato oltre 190 vini in due mattinate di poche ore ognuna, quando ogni professionista serio sa perfettamente che è controindicato, poco serio e da incompetenti degustare piu’ di 30/40 vini in poche ore in una mattinata.
Per questo riporto, a titolo di dimostrazione della improvvisazione di certi personaggi, che da pochi anni si sono buttati a capofitto in questo mondo, pensando fosse una passeggiata per andare in giro per cantine e pranzi/cene a scrocco, di fianco ai punteggi della professionista quelli di un incompetente che si ritiene, a torto, un addetto ai lavori. Purtroppo in era di social e web il settore è sempre piu’ sovraffollato da improvvisati ed incompetenti. Dio ce ne scampi !!
Buona lettura
RELATED REVIEWS 1-20 of 49
-
This gorgeous wine opens with fragrant aromas of violet, wild berry, new …Cellar SelectionSEE FULL REVIEW$99 ( punti improvvisato 92 )
-
This dazzling wine is for Sangiovese purists and fans of extreme finesse. …Cellar SelectionSEE FULL REVIEW$350
-
Earthy aromas of blue flower, rose, underbrush and leather mingle together on …Cellar SelectionSEE FULL REVIEW$139
-
This savory stunner has enticing scents of violet, rose and wild berry …Cellar SelectionSEE FULL REVIEW$119
-
Enticingly fragrant, this opens with heady aromas of rose, violet, new leather, …Cellar SelectionSEE FULL REVIEW$112
-
Fragrant, focused and loaded with finesse, this stunner has enticing scents of …Cellar SelectionSEE FULL REVIEW$85
-
Perfumed, focused and loaded with energy, this radiant red boasts enticing scents …Cellar SelectionSEE FULL REVIEW$100
-
Intense aromas of underbrush, wild berry, new leather and pipe tobacco lead …Cellar SelectionSEE FULL REVIEW$90 ( punti improvvisato 91 )
-
Rose, forest berry, underbrush and new leather are some of the aromas …SEE FULL REVIEW$120 ( punti improvvisato 94 )
-
From one of Montalcino’s little-known gems of an estate, this radiant, savory …Editors’ ChoiceSEE FULL REVIEW$70 ( punti improvvisato 91 )
-
Inviting aromas of ripe wild berry, baking spice and Mediterranean herb are …Cellar SelectionSEE FULL REVIEW$86 ( punti improvvisato 90 )
-
Classic Sangiovese aromas of wild berry, forest floor, rose and new leather …SEE FULL REVIEW$56 ( punti improvvisato 88 )
-
Earthy aromas of underbrush, wild herb and rose mingle with woodland berry …SEE FULL REVIEW$75
-
Aromas of rose, camphor and wild berry mingle with whiffs of leather …SEE FULL REVIEW$90 ( punti improvvisato 92 )
-
Underbrush, ripe black-skinned fruit and camphor aromas mingle with whiffs of toasted …Cellar SelectionSEE FULL REVIEW$70 ( punti improvvisato 87 )
-
Aromas of pine, blue flower, wild herb and menthol take shape on …Cellar SelectionSEE FULL REVIEW$300 ( punti improvvisato 91/92 )
-
Aromas of underbrush, blue flower, camphor and leather escape the glass. The …Editors’ ChoiceSEE FULL REVIEW$65 ( punti improvvisato 87 )
-
Underbrush, leather and red-skinned-berry aromas emerge from the glass. The juicy, balanced …SEE FULL REVIEW$80 ( punti improvvisato 92 )
-
Underbrush, rose, leather and dark spice aromas lift out of the glass …Cellar SelectionSEE FULL REVIEW$60 ( punti improvvisato 86 )
-
Forest-floor, camphor and exotic spice aromas waft out of the glass along …Cellar SelectionSEE FULL REVIEW$105 ( punti improvvisato 93 )
-
Perfumed, focused and loaded with energy, this radiant red boasts enticing scents …Cellar SelectionSEE FULL REVIEW$100
-
Intense aromas of underbrush, wild berry, new leather and pipe tobacco lead …Cellar SelectionSEE FULL REVIEW$90
-
Rose, forest berry, underbrush and new leather are some of the aromas …SEE FULL REVIEW$120 ( punti improvvisato 94 )
-
From one of Montalcino’s little-known gems of an estate, this radiant, savory …Editors’ ChoiceSEE FULL REVIEW$70 ( punti improvvisato 91 )
-
Inviting aromas of ripe wild berry, baking spice and Mediterranean herb are …Cellar SelectionSEE FULL REVIEW$86 ( punti improvvisato 90 )
-
Classic Sangiovese aromas of wild berry, forest floor, rose and new leather …SEE FULL REVIEW$56 ( punti improvvisato 88 )
-
Earthy aromas of underbrush, wild herb and rose mingle with woodland berry …SEE FULL REVIEW$75
-
Aromas of rose, camphor and wild berry mingle with whiffs of leather …SEE FULL REVIEW$90 ( punti improvvisato 92 )
-
Underbrush, ripe black-skinned fruit and camphor aromas mingle with whiffs of toasted …Cellar SelectionSEE FULL REVIEW$70 ( punti improvvisato 87 )
-
Aromas of pine, blue flower, wild herb and menthol take shape on …Cellar SelectionSEE FULL REVIEW$300 ( punti improvvisato 91/92 )
-
Aromas of underbrush, blue flower, camphor and leather escape the glass. The …Editors’ ChoiceSEE FULL REVIEW$65 ( punti improvvisato 89 )
-
Underbrush, leather and red-skinned-berry aromas emerge from the glass. The juicy, balanced …SEE FULL REVIEW$80 ( punti improvvisato 92 )
-
Underbrush, rose, leather and dark spice aromas lift out of the glass …Cellar SelectionSEE FULL REVIEW$60 ( punti improvvisato 86 )
-
Forest-floor, camphor and exotic spice aromas waft out of the glass along …Cellar SelectionSEE FULL REVIEW$105 ( punti improvvisato 93 )
-
Rose-petal, new leather, camphor and pine-forest aromas are front and center on …SEE FULL REVIEW$50
-
Violet, underbrush, ripe berry and camphor aromas waft out of the glass …SEE FULL REVIEW$90 ( punti improvvisato 87 )
-
Aromas of wild berry, violet and forest floor take center stage along …SEE FULL REVIEW$65 ( punti improvvisato 90 )
-
Eucalyptus, red-skinned berry and tobacco aromas are front and center. The savory, …SEE FULL REVIEW$80 ( punti improvvisato 94 )
-
Aromas of dark-skinned berry, Mediterranean herb and leather emerge from the glass. …SEE FULL REVIEW$59 ( punti improvvisato 87 )
-
Underbrush, violet and red-berry aromas take shape in the glass along with …SEE FULL REVIEWN/A ( punti improvvisato 84 )
-
Earthy aromas of tilled soil, black-skinned berry and leather lead the way. …SEE FULL REVIEW$68 ( punti improvvisato 89 )
-
Subtle aromas suggesting forest floor, new leather and baked plum form the …SEE FULL REVIEWN/A ( punti improvvisato 95 )
-
Aromas of rose and red berry gain complexity thanks to dark-spice and …Cellar SelectionSEE FULL REVIEW$49
-
This polished red opens with aromas recalling violet, wild berry, forest floor …SEE FULL REVIEW$60
-
Camphor, rose and new leather aromas form the nose along with a …SEE FULL REVIEW$80
-
Forest-floor, eucalyptus and dark-skinned berry aromas lead the way. The savory palate …SEE FULL REVIEW$70 ( punti improvvisato 94-95 )
-
This opens with intense aromas of rose, crushed mint and forest floor. …SEE FULL REVIEW$65 ( punti improvvisato 92 )
-
Forest-floor, blue-flower and French oak aromas form the nose. The polished palate …SEE FULL REVIEW$65 ( punti improvvisato 88 )
-
Aromas of dark-skinned berry, underbrush and tobacco form the nose. The concentrated, …SEE FULL REVIEW$50
-
Red-skinned berry, forest-floor and new leather aromas waft out of the glass. …SEE FULL REVIEW$45
-
Aromas of black-skinned berry, Mediterranean scrub and toasted oak come together on …SEE FULL REVIEW$85 ( punti improvvisato 95 )
-
Menthol, rose, wild-berry and new leather aromas come together in the glass. …SEE FULL REVIEW$70 ( punti improvvisato 97 )
-
Menthol, dark-spice, new leather and rose aromas form the nose. On the …SEE FULL REVIEW$45
-
This offers earthy aromas of black-skinned berry, leather and tilled soil. The …SEE FULL REVIEW$65
-
Ripe dark-skinned fruit, cooking-spice and new leather aromas emerge from the glass. …SEE FULL REVIEW$65 ( punti improvvisato 94 )
-
Made from organically farmed Sangiovese grapes, this opens with aromas of scorched …SEE FULL REVIEW$60
( Fonte Kerin O’Keefe / Winemag.com )